Selling a House Without a Realtor: What You’ll Still Pay and What You Keep

Save thousands in commission by selling your house without a realtor. Complete FSBO guide with step-by-step process, costs, pros and cons, and expert tips.
how to sell a house without a realtor

Key Takeaways

  • Selling on your own saves $3,300 to $13,300 on a $200,000 to $600,000 home if you still offer the buyer’s agent 2.5% and spend about $1,700 on MLS, photos and an attorney.
  • A sale price 1.7% to 2.2% lower erases that saving. On a $400,000 house that is a sale at $391,700 instead of $400,000.
  • You don’t have to pay the buyer’s agent, but since August 17, 2024 any offer to do so happens off the MLS, and 88% of recent buyers used an agent.
  • NAR’s 2025 Profile reports a $65,000 median gap between FSBO sales ($360,000) and agent-assisted sales ($425,000), though the two groups are different homes.
  • You can exclude up to $250,000 of gain ($500,000 on a joint return) if you owned and lived in the home for two of the last five years.

Table of Contents

Selling without a listing agent saves you the listing side of the commission, 2.5% in the examples here, but you keep less than that once you pay for an MLS listing, photos, an attorney’s review and the buyer’s agent. On a $400,000 house you keep roughly $8,300 of the $10,000, and you give all of it back if the house sells for 2.1% less than an agent would have gotten.

That is the real trade. You are not choosing between paying 5% and paying nothing. You are choosing how much of the buyer’s agent fee to offer, which services to buy back one at a time, and how much price you can afford to lose to thinner marketing.

This guide shows the math from $200,000 to $600,000, works one $400,000 example with a $250,000 mortgage payoff, explains what the 2024 NAR settlement changed for sellers, and covers the paperwork, the tax exclusion and a checklist, so you can decide before you list.

What You Keep, by Sale Price

Find your sale price in the first column and read across. The agent-listed route costs 5% in total, 2.5% to each agent, so every figure to the right is that 5% minus whatever you offer the buyer’s agent, minus the fixed costs of doing the work yourself.

Sale priceAgent-listed selling costsSavings if you offer the buyer’s agent 2.5%Savings if you offer 1.5%Savings if you offer 0%Price drop that erases the 2.5% savings
$200,000$10,000$3,300$5,300$8,3001.7%
$300,000$15,000$5,800$8,800$13,3001.9%
$400,000$20,000$8,300$12,300$18,3002.1%
$500,000$25,000$10,800$15,800$23,3002.2%
$600,000$30,000$13,300$19,300$28,3002.2%

Assumes 2.5% commission on each side on the agent-listed route, with the listing agent covering MLS and photos, and $1,700 in flat-fee MLS, photo and attorney costs at every price. Commissions are negotiable and fixed costs don’t scale with price, so they weigh more on cheaper homes: the break-even drop is 1.7% at $200,000 and 2.2% at $600,000.

Worked example: a $400,000 sale with a $250,000 payoff

The table below shows the $400,000 row in full, with a $250,000 mortgage payoff. The 2.5% commission is an assumption, not a market average. The other costs are commonly quoted midpoints, not figures from a fee schedule: $400 for a flat-fee MLS listing, $300 for photos and $1,000 for an attorney’s review.

Line itemAgent-listedFSBO, offer buyer’s agent 2.5%FSBO, offer 1.5%FSBO, offer 0%
Sale price$400,000$400,000$400,000$400,000
Listing agent (2.5%)$10,000$0$0$0
Buyer’s agent$10,000$10,000$6,000$0
Flat-fee MLS, photos, attorney$0$1,700$1,700$1,700
Total selling costs$20,000$11,700$7,700$1,700
Cash to you after the $250,000 payoff$130,000$138,300$142,300$148,300

Assumes the FSBO house sells at the same $400,000 an agent would have gotten, and that the listing agent covers MLS and photos. Excludes title and escrow fees, transfer taxes, prorated property taxes and buyer concessions, which vary by state and by deal.

The 2.5% column is the one to plan around. The 0% column looks like an $18,300 improvement, but it changes who is willing to show your house, which the next section covers.

Do You Have to Pay the Buyer’s Agent?

Nothing in the NAR settlement requires you to pay the buyer’s agent. What changed on August 17, 2024 is where the offer lives and how the buyer’s agent gets paid, as described in NAR’s settlement FAQs.

  • Compensation offers no longer appear in MLS listings. You can still make and negotiate an offer, but not in an MLS field.
  • Buyer’s agents need a written agreement before touring a home. It states the fee or how it is calculated, and the agent can’t be paid more than the agreement allows, even if a seller offers more.
  • Concessions are separate. Offers to cover part of a buyer’s closing costs can still be communicated on the MLS.

That leaves three ways to handle it. You can state an offer outside the MLS, for example in your own listing materials or directly to agents, and you should ask your flat-fee broker how it handles this, because the MLS rules apply to the broker. You can offer a closing-cost concession instead. Or you can offer nothing and let buyers ask for their agent’s fee in their offer.

The risk of offering nothing is reach, not legality. NAR’s 2025 Profile of Home Buyers and Sellers found that 88% of recent buyers purchased through an agent or broker, so a listing that leaves the entire agent fee to the buyer asks a lot of the people most likely to bid.

How Much Lower Can You Sell Before You Lose Money?

Compare the FSBO result to the agent-listed result on the same house. The last column of the matrix gives the 2.5% break-even at other prices. For the $400,000 example, the agent-listed sale nets $380,000 before the payoff ($400,000 minus $20,000). Add your FSBO selling costs to that figure and you have the lowest price at which selling on your own still breaks even.

Buyer’s agent offerYour selling costsBreak-even pricePrice drop that erases the savings
2.5%$11,700$391,7002.1%
1.5%$7,700$387,7003.1%
0%$1,700$381,7004.6%

Assumes the agent would have sold the same house for $400,000 at 2.5% on each side. Selling costs are from the table above.

NAR’s 2025 Profile reports a median of $360,000 for FSBO sales against $425,000 for agent-assisted sales, a $65,000 gap, and that 40% of FSBO sellers did not actively market their home (NAR’s summary). That comparison covers different houses and different buyers, so it is not a forecast for yours. What it does show is how little cushion the table leaves: a price that lands 2% to 5% short wipes out the savings.

Protect the price in two ways. Price from sold comparables in the last three to six months, not from other sellers’ asking prices, and if you can’t find enough of them, pay for an appraisal before you list. Then get the MLS listing live first, because a listing that isn’t on the MLS typically isn’t on Zillow, Redfin or Realtor.com either.

Before you list, a few targeted projects can raise your price more than they cost; see our guide to ways to increase your home’s value.

If the sale won’t cover your payoff and costs, see our guide to selling a house with negative equity for what to do next.

Selling Without a Realtor With a Mortgage or HELOC

A mortgage doesn’t stop you from selling without an agent. The balance is paid from your proceeds at closing, which is why net proceeds, not sale price, is the number to plan around. On the $400,000 example with a $250,000 payoff, the 2.5% FSBO column leaves $138,300 before title and escrow fees, transfer taxes and prorated property taxes.

Request a payoff statement from your servicer early. It includes interest accrued to a specific date, and the closing agent will typically ask for an updated figure for your closing day. Ask what the lender needs to release the lien and how long that takes after payoff.

If you have a HELOC, it is a second lien that has to be paid off too, and some lenders want a written request to close the line, so ask when you request the payoff. Our HELOC guide explains how the lines work. A home equity agreement is usually settled at sale as well, and how a home equity agreement compares with a HELOC covers the mechanics.

The failure mode is a sale price that doesn’t cover the payoffs plus selling costs. Run the 2.5% column before you set your price floor, because it is the conservative case.

If you need this sale’s proceeds for your next down payment, our guide to buying before you sell covers the ways to buy first, with or without an agent on the sale.

If you have a HELOC, it’s paid off at closing along with your mortgage. See what happens to your HELOC when you sell.

What You Pay For and What You Handle Yourself

Flat-fee MLS, photos and an attorney or title company

Flat-fee MLS listings are commonly quoted from about $100 to $500, and professional photos from a few hundred dollars. Both vary by market and package. Ask what the flat-fee broker handles, how long the listing runs and what happens when an offer arrives, because the MLS recognizes the broker, not you.

Who closes the sale depends on your state. Some states route closings through attorneys, others through title or escrow companies. Ask a local title company which applies before you pay for an attorney review, which is commonly quoted at $500 to $1,500 where it is used.

Disclosures and documents

You must disclose known material defects, and the required form is state-specific. Homes built before 1978 also carry a federal lead-based paint disclosure. The mistake that surfaces after closing is the defect you didn’t mention, so disclose anything you would want to know as a buyer. Gather these before you list:

  • Your deed and a recent payoff statement
  • Your state’s seller disclosure form and, for pre-1978 homes, the lead paint disclosure
  • HOA documents and any pending assessments
  • Receipts and permits for repairs and improvements
  • Your latest property tax bill

Showings and offers

Require a pre-approval letter before a private showing, and read it for the loan type and the amount. Our guide to mortgage preapproval explains how it differs from prequalification. Never show the house alone to someone you haven’t met.

Compare offers by what you would net, not by headline price. A $395,000 offer with approved financing and no sale contingency can beat a $400,000 offer that depends on the buyer selling their own home first. If a buyer asks you to cover closing costs, see how mortgage closing costs work so you know what the request is worth.

Selling to a Neighbor, Relative or Friend

If you already know the buyer, going without an agent makes the most sense, and the paperwork doesn’t shrink. You still need a written purchase contract, the required disclosures, a title search and a closing agent. Skip the agent, not the closing agent.

If the buyer uses a mortgage, the lender orders an appraisal. When it comes in below the agreed price, you renegotiate or the buyer makes up the difference in cash. A price well below market can also carry tax consequences, so run it past a tax professional before you agree to it.

Taxes: What the Home Sale Exclusion Covers

Most homeowners owe no federal tax on the gain. If you owned and used the home as your main home for at least two of the last five years, you can generally exclude up to $250,000 of gain, or $500,000 on a joint return. You generally can’t have claimed the exclusion on another home sold in the previous two years (IRS Topic 701).

Selling costs, including commissions and legal fees, generally reduce your gain, so the FSBO costs above matter for taxes only if your gain exceeds the exclusion. IRS Publication 523 has the worksheets, and a tax professional can confirm your numbers and your state’s rules.

Renting the home out first? You can usually still exclude the gain if you sell within three years of moving out, but depreciation is taxed. Our guide to whether to rent out your house or sell it has the details.

Free: The Home Buyer's Money Checklist
A printable checklist and worksheet: what to save, what to gather and what to compare on every Loan Estimate. Plus our weekly newsletter.
Free. Unsubscribe anytime. Privacy Policy

The Checklist, Start to Closing

  1. Get your payoff statement and your sold comparables.
  2. Set a price floor from the 2.5% column, not from the sale price.
  3. Decide your buyer’s agent offer before you list: a percentage, a concession, or nothing.
  4. Choose a flat-fee MLS broker and ask what is included.
  5. Book photos and prepare your disclosures before the listing goes live.
  6. Require a pre-approval letter before private showings.
  7. Have an attorney or title company review the contract before you sign.
  8. Close through a closing agent, who pays off your loans and sends you the balance.
Buying Your Next Home?

See How Much Homebuying Power You Have

Once you know what you’ll net from the sale, find out what you qualify for on the next one.

See My Buying Power

When an Agent Is the Cheaper Option

A listing agent’s commission is not set by law and is negotiable, so get quotes below the 2.5% assumed above, and consider a flat-fee or limited-service broker that charges for specific tasks. NAR reports that about one in five FSBO sellers eventually hire an agent (NAR’s summary).

Estates, divorces, title problems, a distant move and a tight deadline all make that more likely. If you go that route, our guide to finding a real estate agent covers what to ask. If you are buying again, the mortgage guides start here.

Selling to Buy?

See What Your Proceeds Buy on Your Next Home

Your net proceeds become your next down payment. Run the numbers before you list so you know how much room you have.

Check What I Can Afford

Frequently Asked Questions

How much can I save selling a $200,000 house without a realtor?

At a 2.5% offer to the buyer’s agent, about $3,300 after $1,700 in flat-fee MLS, photo and attorney costs. Offer 1.5% and it is $5,300. The fixed costs take a bigger bite on a cheaper home, so a price just 1.7% lower, about $196,700, erases the saving.

How much can I save selling a $300,000 house without a realtor?

At a 2.5% offer to the buyer’s agent, about $5,800 compared with an agent-listed sale at 2.5% on each side. Offer 1.5% and it is $8,800. Offer nothing and it is $13,300.

How much can I save selling a $400,000 house without a realtor?

At a 2.5% offer to the buyer’s agent, about $8,300 after $1,700 in costs. Offer 1.5% and it is $12,300. Offer nothing and it is $18,300, but you may lose buyers.

How much can I save selling a $500,000 house without a realtor?

At a 2.5% offer to the buyer’s agent, about $10,800. Offer 1.5% and it is $15,800. The break-even is a sale price 2.2% lower, about $489,200.

Do I have to pay the buyer’s agent if I sell without a realtor?

No. Since August 17, 2024, compensation offers can’t appear in MLS listings, and buyer’s agents need a written agreement with their client before touring a home. You can still offer a percentage outside the MLS, offer a closing-cost concession, or let the buyer negotiate their agent’s fee in their offer.

How much lower can the price be before I lose money selling on my own?

If you offer the buyer’s agent 2.5%, between 1.7% on a $200,000 house and 2.2% on a $600,000 house. On $400,000 that is about $391,700. On a $400,000 house the figure is 3.1% if you offer 1.5% and 4.6% if you offer nothing.

Can I sell without a realtor if I still have a mortgage?

Yes. Request a payoff statement from your servicer, and the closing agent pays off the loan from your proceeds. On a $400,000 sale with a $250,000 payoff, the 2.5% FSBO scenario leaves $138,300 before title fees, transfer taxes and tax prorations. A HELOC or home equity agreement is settled at closing too.

Do I need a lawyer to sell without a realtor?

It depends on your state. Some states route closings through attorneys, and in others a title or escrow company handles them. An attorney’s contract review is commonly quoted at $500 to $1,500. Ask a local title company what your state requires before you hire one.

How do I list my house on the MLS without a realtor?

Use a flat-fee MLS broker, commonly quoted at about $100 to $500. The broker enters your listing, and it typically syndicates to the major home-search sites. Ask what is included, how long it runs and who handles offers.

Do I owe taxes when I sell my house?

Often not on the federal gain. If you owned and lived in the home for at least two of the last five years, you can generally exclude up to $250,000 of gain, or $500,000 on a joint return. See IRS Topic 701 and Publication 523, and check your state’s rules.

This article is general information, not legal, tax or financial advice. Commissions, fees, disclosure rules and closing procedures vary by state, and the figures here are illustrative. Check with a licensed real estate attorney, title company or tax professional before you sign.

Picture of Kevin

Kevin

Kevin writes for a variety of websites that cover homeownership, small businesses, marketing, and retail investing.

Reader Interactions

Leave a Comment